Adoption News - 27 - CALIFORNIA - Gay Couple Win Lawsuit Against Adoption Web Site Service in Arizona Posts Profiles Only Of Married Pairs

[ Gay Couples sue over Okla. Adoption Law ] [ Children's Groups appeal overturning of Florida Gay Adoption Ban ]

[ Britain Parliament Oks Gay Adoption ] [ Lesbian Couple from VT Prevail in Adoption Suit ] [ Out of the Shadows ]

[ ACLU Dismayed by 11th Circuit Appeal Upholding Floridas Anti-Gay Adoption Law ] [ US Adoptions Get Easier ]

[ Supreme Court Lets Stand Floridas Gay Adoption Ban ] [ Experts Dispute Bush on Gay Adoption Issue ]

[ Adoptees Deserve Access to Family Health Histories ] [ Committee Defeats Bill to Ban Gays from Adoption ]

[ Civil Debate Over Civil Union ] [ Study Says Foreign Children Adapt Well ] [ Custody After Civil Union Pits States and Judges ]

[ Birth Mothers vs Egg Donor Decision Upheld ] [ Hello I'm Your Sister - Our Father is Donor 150 ]

[ Lund Family Center Capital Campaign Remarks ] [ Unwed Fathers Fight for Babies Placed for Adoption by Mothers ]

[ Adoption Institute Supports Gay Parents ] [ Gays See Shift in Momentum Toward Acceptance in Alabama ]

[ Judge Rejects Law on Gay Adoptions ] [ Perdue vs Mississippi ] [ Gay Marriage Losing Punch as Ballot Issue ]

[ Gay Couple Awaits Adoption Ruling from US Court ] [ China Tightens Adoption Rules, U.S. Agencies Say ]

[ A Taste of US Family Life, But Adoption in Limbo ] [ Gay Couple Win Lawsuit Against Adoption Web Site in Arizona... ]

[ Significant Victory for Same Sex Couples in Oklahoma ] [ Report Urges States To Open Adoptee Records for Adults ]

[ State Court Recognizes Gay Marriage From Elsewhere ] [ Miami Judge Rules Against Florida Gay Adoption Ban ]

[ House Passes Bill Restricting Birth Certificates For Adoptions By Unmarried Couples ]

CALIFORNIA
GAY COUPLE WIN LAWSUIT AGAINST ADOPTION WEB SITE
SERVICE IN ARIZONA POSTS PROFILES ONLY OF MARRIED PAIRS
By Henry K. Lee, San Francisco Chronicle
Wednesday, May 23, 2007

An out-of-state Internet service will no longer post profiles of California residents seeking to adopt children as a result of a settlement with a gay couple from San Jose who sued after their information was barred from the Web site, attorneys in the case said Tuesday.

Michael and Rich Butler, domestic partners since 2000, filed a federal civil rights suit against Adoption.com of Arizona in 2004 after the company told the men it posted profiles only of married, opposite-sex couples.

The adoption company had argued that it was governed by Arizona law, which does not prohibit discrimination against people on the basis of marital status or sexual orientation. It said requiring it to post profiles of same-sex couples would violate its freedom of speech.

But in a March ruling, U.S. District Judge Phyllis Hamilton in San Francisco said California law applies to the defendants and allowed the suit to go forward.

Under the terms of a settlement announced Tuesday, ParentProfiles.com, a sister company to Adoption.com, cannot post profiles of California residents "unless the service is made equally available to all California residents qualified to adopt in California."

That means the defendants have a choice: either "treat everyone in California equally or don't benefit from the state's economy," said Neel Chatterjee, an attorney for the Butlers.

Glen Lavy, an Alliance Defense Fund lawyer representing the company, said Tuesday that ParentProfiles.com will no longer accept profiles from California and will phase out all profiles from California within six months.

"The managers of the adoption profiles believe that it's in the best interests of children to be placed with a married mom and dad," Lavy said. "They believe that when there's an option, children are better off having a married mom and dad than any other circumstance."

It was unclear how many California residents have used the service.

There is no monetary payout as part of the settlement, as the Butlers were never after money, Chatterjee said.

The couple sued under California's Unruh Civil Rights Act, which prohibits businesses from discriminating against customers on a variety of grounds. For at least 20 years, state courts have interpreted the law to require equal treatment of lesbians and gays. Bias based on marital status was the subject of conflicting rulings until the Legislature outlawed such discrimination, effective in 2006.

The Butlers adopted a baby girl in 2004 through a California adoption agency.

"We think it's a great agreement for us because it really ends the discriminatory practice of Adoption.com in the state of California," Rich Butler, 35, said Tuesday. "We hope that they continue doing business in the state, but if they can't comply with the nondiscriminatory policy and they stop doing business in the state, it's still a victory for Californians. We're not allowing them to profit on the back of Californians."

E-mail Henry K. Lee at hlee@sfchronicle.com

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/05/23/BAGKBPVT3D1.DTL  

This article appeared on page B - 12 of the San Francisco Chronicle

Back To Top